The Road Not Yet Taken

The Road Not Yet Taken There is a particular kind of golfer who knows every corner of their home course the way a poet knows a favorite sentence. They know which way the green on the par-3 fourth breaks in the afternoon when the wind swings northwest. They know the exact spot on the 11th fairway where a driver leaves a clean 8-iron and a 3-wood leaves a half-wedge they have never quite trusted. They have played this place in the rain and in the heat and in the golden hour of October when the light turns everything amber and the course becomes something almost unbearably beautiful. They love it. They will always love it.

And somewhere in the back of their mind, in the place where the game lives alongside the ambition it quietly feeds, they have a list. Courses they have watched on television and dreamed about. Names they have whispered to themselves after a good round when the feeling of possibility is still warm and anything seems achievable. Places where the game was born, or perfected, or captured forever on film — places that represent not just great golf but the pilgrimage that every serious golfer eventually feels called to make.

This is the article for the golfer who has not made the trip yet. For the one whose list exists but has never been turned into an itinerary. For the one who is completely, hopelessly, happily obsessed with this game and is finally ready to ask the question that obsession has been building toward for years: Where do I go first?

The answer, as with everything in golf, depends on what you bring to the first tee. What you have. What you are willing to spend. What kind of trip you are building — the pure solo pilgrimage, the guys trip, the version that brings the whole group including the non-golfers who deserve something spectacular of their own while you are out on the course. The answer is different for each of those trips. All of them are worth taking. None of them should be put off any longer.

Here is the map.

Tier One: The Budget Trip — Real Golf, Real Value, Real Memories The budget golf trip is one of the great underrated gifts in American travel, because this country has spent the last thirty years building world-class golf infrastructure at price points that would shock the Pebble Beach accounting department. The secret is knowing where to look, and knowing that affordable does not mean compromised. In the right place, at the right time of year, you can play championship-caliber courses designed by Tom Fazio and Pete Dye and Davis Love III for less than the price of a nice dinner out, stay somewhere comfortable and close to the action, and come home with memories that a $500-a-night resort would struggle to match.

Myrtle Beach, South Carolina is the entry point, the conversation starter, the destination that every budget-conscious golfer eventually arrives at — and for good reason. The Grand Strand is home to over 100 golf courses along the Carolina coast, ranging from casual municipal layouts to genuinely elite designs. Barefoot Resort alone gives you four championship courses in one location — Norman, Love, Fazio, and Dye — all within walking distance of each other, all at prices that let you play two or three rounds a day without requiring a second mortgage. Three-night, three-round stay-and-play packages at solid Myrtle Beach properties start around $315 per person and go up from there depending on the courses and accommodations you choose. This is not a compromise destination. This is the Golf Capital of the World claiming its title honestly.

Beyond Barefoot, the Caledonia Golf & Fish Club and True Blue Golf Club on the Hammock Coast are among the most genuinely beautiful courses in the Southeast — the kind of places that make you stop mid-round and take a slow look around because the setting demands acknowledgment. Myrtle Beach also has the beach. The nightlife. The restaurants. If non-golfing partners are coming along, there is an entire vacation here that exists completely independently of the courses, and that is not always true of the alternatives.

The budget tips for Myrtle Beach are simple and well-tested: book weekday tee times and afternoon rounds whenever possible, as rates drop significantly from weekend morning pricing. Travel in November through February and the prices drop even further while the weather, in the Carolinas, remains entirely playable. Look for packages that bundle lodging and multiple rounds together rather than booking each element separately — the savings are real and the convenience is better.

Tobacco Road in Sanford, North Carolina deserves its own mention for the golfer willing to make a short detour from Myrtle Beach or the Pinehurst region. Mike Strantz's design is one of the most audacious and visually arresting courses in the country — dramatic, unconventional, and genuinely unlike anything most American golfers have ever played. It is not expensive. It is not easy. It is absolutely worth the drive.

For the guys trip specifically, Myrtle Beach has evolved to accommodate groups of all sizes with villa-style accommodations, house rentals, and resort packages built explicitly for the foursome or the group of eight who wants a home base with a putting green in the backyard and enough space to debrief the day's disasters over a cold drink without bothering anyone else. The Myrtle Beach Birdie House offers a 6,000 square foot championship putting green, a Foresight simulator lounge, a gym, sauna, jacuzzi, and cold plunge — built for groups who want more than just a place to sleep and a tee time. This is the budget tier done right.

Estimated cost per person, 4 days/3 rounds: $400–$700, not including flights.

Tier Two: The Affordable Trip — A Step Up in Prestige Without Breaking the Bank The middle tier is where the golf trips you actually tell stories about live. Not the stories about the value you got, though the value here is still excellent. The stories about the courses themselves — courses that have hosted major championships, that appear in Golf Digest's top 100 lists, that have a history and a character and a specific feeling underfoot that stays with you long after you have left.

Pinehurst, North Carolina is the most essential golf destination in America, and it is more accessible than its reputation suggests. The Cradle of American Golf has ten courses on the resort property, with Course No. 2 — Donald Ross's masterpiece and the only course in America to have hosted more single golf championships than any other — sitting at the top of the list for obvious reasons. But it is the breadth of options at Pinehurst that makes it the ideal Tier Two destination. Play No. 2 once for the history and the bragging rights. Play No. 4, Gil Hanse's redesign, for one of the most visually striking modern courses in the country. Play No. 8, Tom Fazio's centennial tribute, for the sheer pleasure of a course that feels like a greatest-hits compilation of everything that makes Pinehurst great.

Packages at Pinehurst Resort start around $310 per person per night for the Bed & Breakfast Golf package, which includes one round per night stayed and the legendary breakfast buffet that has been feeding golfers since 1895. The Premier Golf Package goes higher but delivers unlimited golf — which, for the golfer who wants to play themselves limp over a four-day weekend, is the best deal in resort golf in America. Stay in one of the Carolina Villas with a group of eight, share the four private bedrooms and the common area with the wet bar and the big-screen television, and you have the architecture of one of the great golf trips without the logistics of a far-flung destination.

Pinehurst also answers the couples and mixed-group question better than almost anywhere on this list. The Spa at Pinehurst offers full services in an environment built for relaxation, and the Village of Pinehurst — with its sandy paths, historic homes, boutique shops, and restaurants — is a genuine destination for the non-golfer who needs to be entertained while their partner plays a fifth consecutive round and shows absolutely no signs of stopping. Lake Pinehurst has a white sand beach. There is croquet, tennis, pickleball, a fitness center, and the 18-hole putting course called Thistle Dhu that is, frankly, one of the more enjoyable things you can do on a golf resort that does not involve a full-size club. Pinehurst works for everybody. Not every destination on this list can say that.

The surrounding Sandhills region also offers the budget-adjacent option for groups that want to play Pinehurst No. 2 as the marquee round and fill out the rest of the itinerary with courses like Talamore Golf Club, a Rees Jones design that has been named the Best New Course in the South by Golf Digest and charges a fraction of the Pinehurst resort rates, or Tobacco Road for the adventurous round nobody on the trip will stop talking about.

Scottsdale, Arizona in the fall or winter is the other natural Tier Two destination, particularly for the mixed group where the non-golfers need a full experience of their own. The Fairmont Scottsdale Princess, the Westin Kierland, and the Boulders Resort at Carefree are the headliners here — properties that offer legitimate resort experiences with championship golf, world-class spas, multiple pools, dining that does not feel like an afterthought, and the specific, irreplaceable pleasure of the Sonoran Desert in the cooler months when the weather is perfect and the desert landscape is doing something genuinely extraordinary.

At the Fairmont Scottsdale Princess, golfers can access TPC Scottsdale's Stadium Course — the course that hosts the Waste Management Phoenix Open, where the 16th hole transforms into one of the loudest, most electric environments in professional golf every February. Playing that course outside of tournament week, with the grandstands gone and the stadium quiet, is its own kind of experience. The Boulders Resort, set among the ancient volcanic rock formations north of Scottsdale, has two Jay Morrish-designed courses built directly into and around the boulders themselves, and a 33,000 square foot spa that consistently ranks among the best resort spas in the American Southwest. The Four Seasons at Troon North offers access to both the Monument and Pinnacle courses — two of the early designs that put Scottsdale on the golf map — in an environment of private casitas and desert views that makes the non-golfer in the group feel like they got the better end of the deal. Scottsdale has over 200 golf courses, over 300 days of sunshine per year, and an infrastructure built around the idea that the golfer and the non-golfer should both arrive home equally satisfied. It delivers on that consistently.

Estimated cost per person, 4 days/3 rounds: $800–$1,500, not including flights.

Tier Three: The Dream Trip — The Golf Pilgrimages Worth Saving For There are golf destinations and there are golf pilgrimages, and the difference between them is this: you visit a destination and you have a great time. You make a pilgrimage and something changes in you, permanently, and every round you play afterward is in some way informed by having been there. The trips in this tier are pilgrimages. They are the ones that every golfer who plays long enough and deeply enough eventually feels pulled toward. They cost more. They are worth every dollar.

Bandon Dunes, Oregon is, without argument, the best golf resort in America. Mike Keiser built it on the rugged southern Oregon coast in 1999 with a single operating philosophy: golf as it was meant to be played. Walking only. No carts. Six distinct links-style courses — Bandon Dunes, Pacific Dunes, Bandon Trails, Old Macdonald, Sheep Ranch, and Bandon Preserve — all carved into 1,000 acres of coastal dunes above the Pacific Ocean, all designed by some of the most celebrated minimalist architects in the game. Three of the resort's courses regularly appear in Golf Digest's America's Top 100. There is no place in the world where you can play five top-100 courses at a single resort. Not one. Bandon Dunes exists in its own category.

The beauty of Bandon — beyond the courses themselves, which are as good as advertised — is the pricing structure, which was designed by someone who understood that the resort should be accessible to any golfer who loved the game enough to make the journey. A peak season round in July through September costs around $350, which is roughly half the price of a round at Pebble Beach. And Bandon's same-day replay is half price — meaning two rounds on two different top-100 courses in a single day costs around $525 total. Play a third round? That one is on the house. In the off-season, from December through January, the price of a round drops to around $110. Which means two top-100 courses in one day, in the Oregon winter, runs approximately $165. There is no better value in elite golf anywhere on earth.

Getting to Bandon requires some logistics — Eugene Airport is about two and a half hours away, and Southwest Oregon Regional Airport at North Bend is 35 minutes from the resort but has limited commercial service. This is the catch, and it is a real one. Bandon is not convenient. Bandon is a commitment. It is the kind of place you plan for, fly to early, stay at for five days minimum, and leave understanding why people go back every year for the rest of their lives. Reviewers on every platform say the same thing: the moment they walked off the course after the first round, they were already planning the return trip.

For groups, Bandon's Grove Cottages sleep up to sixteen people in private rooms and are the ideal base for a group of eight to twelve. Packages through outfitters like Premier Golf and TripCaddie run approximately $4,500 to $5,300 per person for four nights with multiple rounds included, which sounds like a lot until you start calculating what you are actually getting, and then it sounds like exactly what it is: a fair price for the best golf experience available on American soil.

The one honest caveat about Bandon for the mixed group: the resort was built for golfers and makes no secret of it. The dining is excellent and the setting is spectacular, but Bandon Dunes is not a spa resort. It is not a beach resort. Non-golfers can be happy there — the Oregon coast is beautiful, the dinners are genuinely good, the atmosphere is warm and welcoming — but the resort's entire architecture is oriented toward the person who wants to play 36 holes today and 36 holes tomorrow and then do it again the day after that. For the pure golf trip, it is unmatched. For the mixed group where the non-golfer needs their own program, it works better as a standalone guys trip paired with a different destination for the combined travel.

Pebble Beach, California is the other American pilgrimage, and unlike Bandon it answers the mixed-group question beautifully. The Pebble Beach Resort encompasses multiple properties — The Lodge at Pebble Beach, The Inn at Spanish Bay, and Casa Palmero — along with four courses including the iconic Pebble Beach Golf Links, Spyglass Hill, and Spanish Bay, which plays as a genuine links course along the California coast and is the most underrated round in the resort's collection. The Lodge at Pebble Beach is one of the most famous hotels in American golf, perched at the edge of the 18th green with views of the Pacific that exist in a category of their own.

Pebble Beach is not inexpensive. A round on the Golf Links costs $675 in peak season, which is the most expensive public round in America. But it is, by many measures, the most beautiful course in America, and standing on the 7th tee — the tiny par-3 that sits above the Pacific with the ocean as the backdrop — is one of the genuinely transcendent moments this game offers. The 18th hole, a par-5 that runs along the cliff's edge above the water, is as good a finishing hole as any on earth. You are not just playing golf at Pebble Beach. You are playing golf on a stage that has hosted six U.S. Opens and produced some of the most famous moments in the history of the game, and the course carries that weight in every step.

For the mixed group and the couples trip, Pebble Beach is perfect. The spa at The Lodge is world-class. The surrounding area — Carmel-by-the-Sea, the Big Sur coastline, the Monterey Bay Aquarium, the restaurants in Pacific Grove — constitutes one of the most beautiful stretches of California coast, and a non-golfer could spend a week in Carmel without ever setting foot on a fairway and have a genuinely spectacular trip. Pebble Beach is the dream trip for the couple who both deserve something extraordinary, just in different directions.

Scotland — St. Andrews and the Links of Fife and Angus is the apex. Not just a trip. A reckoning. A confrontation with the place where this game was invented and where, if you pay attention, you can still feel the ghost of every golfer who has ever stood on the first tee of the Old Course and looked out at 600 years of history and understood, maybe for the first time, what they have been chasing all along.

The Old Course at St. Andrews is the oldest and most iconic golf course in the world, and getting on it requires either extraordinary planning or extraordinary luck. Tee times are allocated through a combination of guaranteed reservation packages booked 12 to 24 months in advance through authorized providers, an advance application process called the Swilcan Package which operates as a lottery for the following year, a daily ballot drawn two days before play, and a singles walk-up for solo golfers willing to show up the day before and take their chances. The smart move for a first-time group is to book through an authorized provider — companies like Epic Golf Travel and PerryGolf have guaranteed tee times on the Old Course and build packages around them. Pricing for these packages starts around $5,990 per person and runs to $7,750 or more depending on lodging, duration, and the courses included beyond the Old Course.

But here is the thing about a Scotland golf trip that the pricing alone does not capture: you are not buying a tee time. You are buying a week that includes the Old Course, yes, and also Kingsbarns — the spectacular clifftop links that opened in 2000 and plays as if it has been there for a century — and Carnoustie, where the Open Championship has been decided in conditions that have broken the best players in the world, and perhaps Crail or Dumbarnie Links or the Castle Course if the itinerary allows. You are buying the town of St. Andrews itself, which is one of the most charming medieval university towns in Europe and where the pubs serve exactly what they should serve after a round on the links. You are buying the specific, unrepeatable experience of walking off the Swilcan Bridge and feeling the weight of every name that has ever crossed it.

For the non-golfer making this trip, Scotland rewards completely. Edinburgh is one of the great cities in Europe — the castle, the Royal Mile, the whisky distilleries, the food scene that has transformed in the last decade into something genuinely world-class. The Scottish Highlands are an hour from St. Andrews and constitute some of the most dramatic landscape anywhere on earth. A Scotland golf trip built properly — with a few days in Edinburgh before the golf week, and perhaps a day or two in the Highlands afterward — is one of the great travel experiences available to any person, not just golfers.

Peak season runs from June through August and commands the highest prices and the heaviest demand. The shoulder months of April, May, and September offer a meaningful balance of good weather and slightly more accessible pricing, and October golf in Scotland — played into the wind with the fireside waiting at the 19th hole — is something a person does not easily forget.

Estimated cost per person, Bandon Dunes (5 days): $4,500–$5,500, not including flights. Estimated cost per person, Pebble Beach (3–4 days): $2,500–$4,500, not including flights. Estimated cost per person, Scotland (7–10 days): $6,000–$10,000+, including international flights.

The Trip You Build for Everyone A note on the mixed group — the foursome or the group of couples where the golfers want to play and the non-golfers want their own adventure. This is a solvable equation, but it requires choosing the destination with the non-golfer's experience as an equal priority, not an afterthought.

Pinehurst is the best mid-range answer. The spa, the village, the lake, the resort's breadth of amenities — it works for everyone without requiring anyone to pretend they are having a better time than they are. Scottsdale is the best warm-weather answer, particularly at the Boulders or the Four Seasons, where the spa culture and the desert experience give the non-golfer a genuinely luxurious program. Pebble Beach is the best premium answer — the Carmel coast is one of the most beautiful places in America and requires no golf to justify the trip. And Scotland is its own category, because the country itself is the destination and the golf is simply the most beautiful way to experience it.

The wrong answer is to choose a destination based entirely on the golf and assume the non-golfer will figure out something to do. They will. But the trips that get repeated — the ones that become annual traditions, that expand from four people to eight, that turn into the thing your group does every fall — are the trips where everybody comes home satisfied.

Honorable Mentions: The Ones That Deserved Their Own Tier Some destinations do not fit cleanly into a single tier because they straddle the line between affordable and elite in ways that make them genuinely unique. These two deserve their own conversation.

Big Cedar Lodge, Branson, Missouri — The Ozarks Surprise

If you have never heard of Big Cedar Lodge as a golf destination, that is about to change. Johnny Morris, the founder of Bass Pro Shops, has quietly built one of the most extraordinary golf properties in America in the hills of the Missouri Ozarks near Branson — and the rest of the country is only beginning to catch up to what Midwesterners have known for years. USA TODAY readers named it America's Best Golf Resort, and the case is not hard to make. The property features five distinct championship courses designed by a roster of architects that reads like a hall of fame ballot: Tom Fazio's Buffalo Ridge, Coore and Crenshaw's Ozarks National, a 13-hole short course from Gary Player, a par-3 course by Jack Nicklaus, and the headliner — Payne's Valley, Tiger Woods' first-ever public course design, named in honor of three-time major champion Payne Stewart, who grew up in nearby Springfield and remains one of the most beloved figures in the history of the game.

Payne's Valley opened in 2020 with a celebrity exhibition match — Woods and Justin Thomas against Rory McIlroy and Justin Rose — that announced the course's arrival to the world. The design sprawls across 85 acres of zoysia fairways through the dramatic Ozark terrain, wide enough to be playable for the average golfer while offering the strategic depth to challenge a scratch player. The 19th hole — a par-3 island green designed by Morris himself, surrounded by streams and waterfalls cascading down exposed rock walls — is one of the most visually spectacular bonus holes in American golf. Payne's Valley sits at number 81 on Golf Digest's America's Top 100 Public Courses for 2025. Buffalo Ridge is at 94. Both on the same property.

A full 4-night, 4-round package — playing Cliffhangers, Buffalo Ridge, Ozarks National, and Payne's Valley — runs approximately $2,199 per person in double occupancy. That is four rounds at a Top 100 resort for a price that fits comfortably between Tier One and Tier Two, which is exactly what makes Big Cedar Lodge the most interesting value proposition on this entire list. It is not budget golf. It is not Pebble Beach pricing. It is somewhere in the best possible middle, and it is a drive rather than a flight for over a third of the American population.

For the group trip, Big Cedar's lodge-style accommodations, the Bass Pro Shops atmosphere, the Ozarks scenery, and the Branson entertainment corridor nearby give the non-golfers and the mixed group enough to work with. It is, in the best possible way, the most American golf resort in America — built around the idea that great land, great golf, and the simple pleasure of the outdoors are things worth celebrating without apology.

Northern Michigan — The Great Lakes Secret

Northern Michigan is one of the most underrated golf destinations in the United States, and golfers who have been keeping the secret are going to be slightly annoyed that it is appearing in print. Golf Magazine has named the Traverse City region one of the top six golf destinations in the country. Golf Digest ranked Grand Traverse Resort among its Top 75 Golf Resorts in America. And yet, to a significant portion of the country, Northern Michigan remains something heard about from a friend who went once and never stopped talking about it.

The anchor is Arcadia Bluffs, a 36-hole facility perched on the bluffs above Lake Michigan that plays like someone took the finest links golf in Ireland, transplanted it to the American Midwest, and added views of the Great Lakes that justify the drive before you even pull a club from the bag. The Bluffs Course and the South Course together constitute what may be the most visually dramatic 36 holes in the Midwest, and the pricing — especially compared to what the same quality of golf costs on either coast — is the kind of value that golfers who make the trip mention first when they tell the story.

Surrounding Arcadia Bluffs is an ecosystem of courses that would constitute a legitimate bucket list trip on their own. Forest Dunes in Roscommon features The Loop, a Tom Doak design that can be played in either direction — clockwise or counterclockwise — making it the only reversible course of its kind in America outside of the Old Course at St. Andrews. The Jack Nicklaus-designed Bear at Grand Traverse Resort has spent decades as the region's most demanding test. And Greywalls at the Marquette Golf Club, designed by Mike DeVries, is the hidden gem of the Upper Peninsula — a dramatic layout on the shores of Lake Superior with peak walking rates around $59 that would seem impossible if the course were located anywhere near a major city.

The Traverse City area compounds its appeal for the mixed group with one of the most genuinely charming off-course environments in American golf travel. The wine scene on the Leelanau and Old Mission peninsulas — the "Napa of the North" — the brewery culture, the downtown waterfront, the cherry orchards, the local restaurants — Traverse City is a complete destination that the non-golfer has no reason to feel excluded from. Stay-and-play packages at Grand Traverse Resort, A-Ga-Ming on the shores of Torch Lake, or Shanty Creek in Bellaire bundle lodging and multiple rounds at prices that remain among the best values in American golf travel. A four-day trip playing three or four genuinely top-tier courses can be assembled for $600 to $1,000 per person — budget-tier pricing for Tier Two quality golf in a setting that the Great Lakes make extraordinary.

The season runs June through October, and the courses book early with Midwestern regulars who have been coming back for decades. Book ahead. Go at least once. You will understand the loyalty the moment you stand on the bluffs at Arcadia and look out at Lake Michigan and realize the golfer who told you about this place did you one of the better favors of your life.

Start Somewhere The list in the back of every golfer's mind is real and the pull of it is real and the longer it goes unaddressed the more it becomes a vague ambition rather than an actual plan. The trick is to turn it into a plan.

Start with Myrtle Beach if the budget is the binding constraint. You will play more golf for less money than almost anywhere in America, and you will come home knowing which tier you are ready to aim at next. Go to Pinehurst if the history matters and you want to stand somewhere that has meant something to this game for over a century. Go to Scottsdale in October when the desert is perfect and the courses are in the best shape of the year. Go to Bandon Dunes when you are ready to understand what golf was supposed to feel like before it became convenient. Go to Pebble Beach when you want to stand on the 7th hole and let the Pacific remind you that the game is larger than any score you have ever shot. And go to Scotland when you are ready to make the pilgrimage that every honest golfer owes the game eventually — to walk where it started, on the ground where it was invented, and understand for the first time where everything you love about this came from.

The road is there. The only question is when you decide to take it.

Foresome.com